means;for sustaining this purpose is still that of the onginal scheme~a control of oil transportation giving special privileges in rates. It is now thirty-two years since Mr. Rockefeller applied the fruitful idea of the South Improvement Company to the Standard Oil Company of Ohio, a prosperous oil refinery of Cleveland, with a capital of $i,oo6,ooo and a daily capacity for handling ~,;co barrels of crude oil. And what have we as a result? What is the Standard Oil Company to-day? First, what is its o?ganisation? It is no longer a trust. As we have seen, the trust was obliged to liquidate in 1892. It became a "trust in liquidation," and there it remained for some five years. It seemed to have come into a state of stationary liquidation, for at the end of 1892477,881 shares were uncancelled; at the end of 1896 the same number were out. The situation of the great corporation was indeed curious. There began to be comments on it, for complications arose~ne over taxes. In 1893 an auditor in Ohio tried to collect taxes on 225 shares of the Standard Oil Trust. The owner refused to pay and took the case into court., He won it. The Standard Oil Trust is an unlawful organisation, said the court. Its certificates have no validity. It would seem strange that a certificate which was void to all purpose would still be valid as to taxable purpo,5e5.* Here was an anomaly indeed. The certificates were drawing big quarterly dividends, had a big market value, but were illegal. Owners of small certificates naturally refused ~ exchange. In 1897 it took '94½ shares in the Standard Oil Trust to bring back one share in each of the twenty companies. Thus one share in the Standard Oil Company of Ohio~ worth t~~enty-seven shares in the Standard Oil Trus(.' If a man owned twenty-five shares he got only fractional parts of a share in each company. On these fractional parts he received no dividends, it not being considered practical

to consider such small sums. To raise his twenty-five shares to 194, and so secure dividends, took a good sum of money, since Standard Oil Trust shares were worth at least 340 then, But why should he trouble? He received his quarterly divi dends promptly, and they were large! He paid no taxes, for stock was illegal! The trustees were not pushing him to liquidate. Besides, it was' doubtful if they could do anything. Joseph Choate said they could not. On May 3, 1894, before the attorney-general of New York, in an application for the forfeiture of the charter of the Standard Oil Company of New York, Mr. Choate said: "I happen to own 100 shares in the Standard Oil Trust, and I have never gone forward and claimed my aliquot share. Why not? Because I would get ten in one company, and ten in another company, and two and three-fifths in another company. "There is no power that this company can exercise to compel me and other indifferent certificate holders, if you please, to come forward and convert our trust certificates." If there was a way, the trustees were indifferent to it. They evidently were contented to let things alone. It is quite possible that they would have been holding to-day 477,881 uncancelled shares of'Standard Oil Trust if it had not been for the irrepressible George Rice. Since October, 1892, Mr. Rice had held a Standard Oil Trust certificate for six shares. He had never cancelled it. He had received no invitation to do so. t He received his dividends regularly on it. Later, he purchased one share, called "assignment of legal title"-the new form given the trust certificate-and on this he received dividends, exactly as on the original trust certificate. Finally Mr. Rice made up his mind, without knowing any of the facts of the liquidation outlined above, that there was no intention to carry out the dissolution, that some means of evasion had been devised, and he proposed to find out what it was.

To do this he transferred his assignment of legal title to an agent with the order to liquidate it. A long correspondence followed between Mr. Kemper, Mr. Rice's agent, and Mr. )odd, who objected to making the transfer on the ground that it cut the share into a "multitude of almost infinitesimal fractionS of corporate shares." They were obviating this difficulty, Mr. Dodd said, by purchasing certificates calling for one or a few shares and uniting them until sufficient were had by one party to call for the issue of full corporate shares. Mr. Kemper insisted, however, and finally received scrip for his share. "Infinitesimal" it was, indeed, ~ of one share in one company, :7o~ of one share in another, and so on through nineteen constituent companies.* Arguing from these experiences and what else he could gather, Mr. Rice decided that the trust was not dissolved and had no intention of doing so. Furthermore, he argued that the scheme was one to entice the small shareholders to sell their shares and thus enable the trustees to increase their holdings! And he sought legal counsel in Ohio as to the possibility of bringing suit against the Standard Oil Company of Ohio for failing to obey the court's orders in March, 1892. The attorneys, one of whom was Mr. Watson, advised Mr. Rice to lay his facts before the attorney-general of the state, Frank S. Monnett. Like Mr. Watson, when he brought his suit, Mr. Monnett was young and held firmly to the belief that the business of an attorney-general is to enforce the laws. The facts Mr. Rice and his counsel laid before him seemed to him to indicate that the Standard Oil Company of Ohio had taken advantage of the leniency of the court in allowing it time to disent~ngle itself from the trust, and had devised a skilful plan to evade the judgment pronounced against it five years before. He asked Mr. Rice and his attorneys to go with him and lay the case before the judges of the Supreme Court in chambers, and ask if it did not justify proceedings against' the company. The judges agreed with the attorney-general and ordered him to bring the company before the court for contempt. Information was filed in November, 1897. The suit which followed proved one of the most sensational ever instituted against the Standard Oil Combination. The first substantial point gained by the attorney-general in the proceedings was securing answers to a long series of questions concerning the history of the operations of the Standard Oil Company of Ohio, both within and without the trust. These answers were made by the president of that company, who was at the same time the president of the trust, John D. Rockefeller. They furnish a mass of facts of value and interest, and they include the minutes of the meeting at which the trust was dissolved on March II, 1892, as well as the minutes of all the quarterly meetings the liquidating trustees held from 1892 to October, 1897. It was from the information obtained from this set of questions that Mr. Monnett secured proof that the liquidation scheme had been held up, as Mr. Rice claimed. The minutes showed, as related in Chapter XIV, that from November, 1892, to March, 1896, 477,881 shares were reported every three months to the trustees as uncancelled. In July, 1896, the number fell suddenly to 477,880. George Rice had succeeded in having his assignment of legal title liquidated! Mr. Monnett learned from the result of this inquiry another suggestive fact, that while only ~~ne share was cancelled in the five years before the contempt proceedings were brought, in the first three months after, 100,583 shares were cancelled! * It took Mr. Monnett some six months to secure the answers from Mr. Rockefeller, but his information was still incomplete, and he asked the court to appoint a master commissioner with power to examine the officers, affairs and books of the Standard, to take testimony within or without the state, and to report. This was done, the commissioner holding his first court at the New Amsterdam Hotel, in New York, on October II and I 2, 1898. Mr. Rockefeller was the only witness examined at the sessions, and his deliberation and self-control, his almost detached attitude as a witness, were the subject of ~ ~remark by more than one observer. He answered no question ~promptly. He had the air of reflecting always before he spoke. He consulted frequently with his counsel. His counsel, his col:'~L leagues who were present, the counsel of the prosecution, were sometimes irate, never Mr. Rockefeller. From beginning to end he was the soul of self-possession. His only sign of impatience-if it was impatience-was an incessant slight tapping of the arm of his chair with his white fingers. The outcome of this examination of Mr. Rockefeller was that Mr. Monnett and his colleagues called for those boQks of the trust which would show exactly how the original trust certificates had been liquidated. It was then that the copies of the transfers of Mr. Rockefeller's trust certificates and of his assignments of legal title printed in the Appendix, Number 54, were obtained. Although Mr. Monnett had added to his knowledge of the Standard's operations between 1892 and 1898, he was not yet convinced that the Standard Oil Company of Ohio was conducting its own business. He had found that, in spite of the order of the court in 1892, 13,593 shares of that company's stock were still outstanding in trust certificates. He knew these certificates drew dividends. Was the company paying money directly or indirectly to the liquidating trustees?'They said no, that they had been paying no dividends since 1892, that the money paid the holders of trust certificates came from the other nineteen companies, that all their earnings had been used in improving their plant, or were invested in government bonds. Besides, said they, we are not passed. As soon as he had sufficient evidence he had filed petitions against all four of them. Now, these petitions were filed about the time he demanded the books showing the earnings of the Standard Oil Company of Ohio, for use in his contempt case. It was the~old story of one suit being used as a shield in another. A witness cannot be made to incriminate himself. The reasons F. B. Squire, the secretary of the Standard Oil Company of Ohio, gave for refusing to produce the books as ordered by the court were as follows:

1st. Because they are demanded in an action instituted against the Standard Oil

Company for contempt of court, and for the purpose of proving said company guilty of contempt in order that the penalties for contempt may be inflicted upon it and its

officers; and I am informed that, to enforce their production in such a case and for such a purpose, is an unreasonable search and seizure. znd. Because the books disclose facts and circumstances which may be used against the Standard Oil Company, tending to prove it guilty of offences made criminal by an act of the Legislature of Ohio, passed April 19, 1898, entitled "An Act to define trusts and to provide, for criminal penalties, civil damages, and the punishment of cotporations," etc. 3rd. Because they disclose facts and circumstances which may be used against myself personally as an officer of said company, tending to prove me guilty of offences "made criminal by the act aforesaid.*

All through the winter of 1898 and 1899, up to the end of

March, when the commission declared the taking of testimony closed, the wrangle over the production of the books went on. Depositions had begun to be taken at the same time in the cases against the constituent companies for violation of the anti-trust laws, and by the time the contempt case was closed in March, 1899, the exasperation of both sides had reached fever pitch. Nor did the judgment of the court quiet it, for three judges voted for finding the company guilty of contempt, and three for clearing it. Unsatisfactory as this was, Mr. Monnett still had his anti * the thrifty concern we used to be. Mr. Monnett demanded proof from their books. The secretary of the company, on advice of his counsel, Virgil P. Kline, refused to pr the' books asked for, on the ground that they would incriminate the company. The court supported Mr. Monnett, and ordered the company to produce those of their records showing the gross earnings since 1892; and what had been done with them. The order met with a second refusal. Such was the status of the proceedings when Mr. Monnett received an anonymous communication stating that, about the time the company was ordered by the court to produce its records, a great quantity of books had been taken from the ~St'~andard's office in Cleveland and burned. An investigation was at once made by the attorney-general, and a number of witnesses examined. The fact of the burning of sixteen boxes of books from the Standard offices in Cleveland was established, but these books, the officers of the company contended, were not the ones wanted by Mr. Monnett. "Then produce the ones we want,' ordered the court. But, on the ground that such records might incriminate them, the officers still refused. The fact was, the Standard Oil Company of Ohio was in a very tight place, and it is difficult to see how an examination their books could have failed to incriminate not only it, but three other of the constituent companies of the trust which held charters from the same state. These three companies were the Ohio Oil Company, which produced oil; the Buckeye Pipe Line, which transported it; and the Solar Refining Company, which refined it. Mr. Monnett had learned enough about these organisations in the course of his investigations since November, 1897, to convince him that these companies-all of them enormously profitable-were, for all practical purposes, one and the same combination, and that they were all working with the Standard Oil Company of Ohio, and that their oper ations were in direct violation of a state anti-trust law recently expected and through which he

suits, which

trust through he did secure much further evidence that the four Standard cornparnes in Ohio were practically one concern so shrewdly and "~secretly handled that they were evading not only the laws of I the state, but that policy of all states which decrees that it is

unsafe to allow men to work together in industrial combina

tions without charters defining their privileges, and subjecting

them to reasonable examinations and publicity. Mr. Monnett's

work on these suits came to an end with the expiration of his

term in January, 1900, and the suits were suppressed by his

successor, John M. Sheets! Unfinished as they were, they

/were of the greatest value in dragging into the light infor

mation concerning the methods and operations of the Stand-

ard Oil Combination to which the public has the right, and

which it must digest if it is to succeed in working out a

(legal harness for combinations which, like the Standard, de

in and freedom to do what they like and do it secretly.

The only refuge offered in the United States for the

Standard Oil Trust in 1898, when the possibility arose by

these suits of the state of Ohio taking away the charters of

four of its important constituent companies for contempt of

court and violation of the anti-trust laws of the state, lay in the

corporation law of the state of New Jersey, which had just

been amended, and here it settled. Among the twenty corn

panies which formed the trust was the Standard Oil Company

of New Jersey, a corporation for manufacturing and market-

mg petroleum products. Its capital was $10,000,000. In June,

11899, this capital of $10,000,000 was increased to one of $i 10,-

000,000, and into this new organisation was dumped the entire

1Standard aggregation. The old trust certificates outstanding

and the assignments of legal title which had succeeded them

were called in, and for them were given common stock of the

new Standard Oil Company. The amount of this stock which

had been issued, in January, 1904, when the last report was

made, was $97,448,800. Its market value at that date was $643,162;080. How it is divided is of course a matter of private -Dncern. The number of stockholders in 1899 was about 3,500, ccording~to Mr. Archbold's testimony to the Interstate Corn- Commission, but over one-half of the stock was owned by the directors, and probably nearly one-third was owned by Mr. Rockefeller himself. The companies which this new Standard Oil Company has bought up with its stock are numerous and scattered. They consist of oil-producing companies like the South Penn Oil Company, the Ohio Oil Company, and the Forest Oil Company; of transporting companies like the National Transit Company, the Buckeye Pipe Line Company, the Indiana Pipe Line Company, and the Eureka Pipe Line Company; of manufacturing and marketing companies like the Atlantic Re- fining Company of Pennsylvania, and the Standard Oil Cornpanies of many,states-New York, Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, Iowa; of foreign marketing concerns like the Anglo-American Company. In 1892 there were twenty of these constituent companies. There have been many added since, in whole or part, like gas companies; new producing concerns, made necessary by developments in California, Kansas and Texas; new marketing concerns for handling oil directly in Germany, Italy, Scandinavia and Portugal. What the total value of the companies owned by the present Standard Oil Company is it is impossible to say. In 1892, when the trust was on trial in Ohio, it reported the aggregate capital of its twenty companies as $102,233,700, and the appraised value was given as $121,- 631,312.63; that is, there was an excess of about $19,000,000. In 1898, when Attorney-General Monnett of Qhio had the Standard Oil Company of the state on trial for contempt of court, he tried to find out from Mr. Rockefeller what the surplus of each of the various companies in the trust was at that date. Mr. Rockefeller answered: "I have not in my posvessel~ cars, wharves, docks, and piers; lay and operate pipelines; erect and operate telegraph and telephone lines, and lines for conducting electricity; enter into and carry out con~racts of every kind pertaining to his business; acquire, use, and grant licenses under patent rights; purchase, or otherwise acquire, hold, sell, assign, and transfer shares of capital stock and bonds or other evidences of indebtedness of corporations, and exercise all the privileges of ownership, including voting upon the stocks so held; carry on its business and have offices and agencies therefor in all parts of the world, and hold, purchase, mortgage, and convey real estate and personal property outside the state of New Jersey. These privileges ~ are, of course, subject to the laws of the state or country in which the company operates. If it is contrary to the laws of a state for a foreign corporation to hold real estate in its boundaries, a company must be chartered in the state. Its stock, of c6urse, is sold to the New Jersey corporation, so that it amounts to the same thing as far as the ability to do business is concerned. It will be seen that this really amounts to a special charter allowing the holder not only to do all that is specified, but to create whatever other power it desires, except banking.* A comparison of this summary of powers with those granted by the South Improvement Company shows that in sweep of charter, at least, the Standard Oil Comp,~~~y o~f to-day has as great power as its famous progenitor.t ~ -~ The profits of the present Standard Oil Company are enormotis. For five years the dividends have been averaging about forly -five million dollars a year, or nearly fifty per cent. on its capitalisation, a sum which capitalised at five per cent. would give $900,000,000. Of course this is not all that the combination makes in a year. It allows an annual average of session or power data showing . . . the amount of such surplus money in their hands after the payment of the last dividends." Then Mr. Rockefeller~proceeded to repeat as the last he knew of the value of the holdings of the trust the list of values given six years before.* This list has continued to be cited ever since as authoritative. There is a later one, whether Mr. Rockefeller had it in his "possession or power," or not, in 1898. It is the last trustworthy valuation of which the writer knows, and is found in testimony taken in 1899, in a private suit to which Mr. Rockefeller was party. It is for the year 1896. This shows the "total capital and surplus" of the twenty companies to have been, on December 31 of that year, some-thing over one hundred and forty-seven million dollars, nearly forty-nine millions of which was scheduled as "undivided profits." t Of course there has been a constant increase in value since 1896. The new Standard Oil Company is managed by a board of fourteen directors.t They probably collect the dividends of the constituent companies and divide them among stockholders in exactly the same way the trustees of 1882 and the liquidating trustees of 1892 did. As for the charter under which they are operating, never since the days of the South Improvement Company has Mr. Rockefeller held pnvileges. so in harmony with his ambition. By it he can do all kinds of mining, manufacturing, and trading business; transport goods and merchandise by land and water in any manner; buy, sell, lease, and improve lands; build houses, structures, 5.77 per cent. for deficit, and it carries always an ample reserve fund. When we remember that probably one-third of this immense annual revenue goes into the hands of Jo D. Rockefeller, that probably ninety per cent. of it goes to-the few men who make up the "Standard Oil family," and that it must every year be invested, the Standard Oil Company becomes a much more serious public matter than it was in 1872, when it stamped itself as willing to enter into a conspiracy to raid the oil business~as a much more serious concern than in the years when it openly made warfare of business, and drove from the oil industry by any means it could invent all who had the hardihood to enter it. For, consider what must be done with the greater part of this $45,000,000. It must be invested. The oil business does not demand it. There is plenty of reserve for all of its ventures. It must go into other industries. Naturally, the interests sought will be allied to oil. They will be gas, and we have the Standard- Oil crowd steadily acquiring the gas interests of the country. They will;. be railroads, for on transportation all industries depend, and, besides, railroads are one of the great consumers of oil products and must be kept in line as buyers. And we have the directors of the Standard Oil Company acting as directors on nearly all of the great railways of the country, the New York Central, New York, New Haven and Hartford, Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul, Union Pacific, Northern Pacific, Delaware, Lackawanna and Western, Missouri Pacific, Missouri, Kansas and Texas, Boston and Maine, and other lesser roads. They will go into copper, and we have the Amalgamated scheme. They will go into steel, and we have Mr. Rockefeller's enormous holdings in the Steel Trust. They will go into banking, and we have the National City Bank and its allied institutions in New York City and Boston, as well as a long chain running over the country. No one who has followed this history can expect these holdings will be acquired on a inayket. Buy cheap and sell high is a rule of business, when you control enough money and enough banks you always manage that a stock you want shall be temporarily cap. No value is destroyed for you-only for the original owner. This has been one of Mr. Rockefeller's mostsuccessful i~nan~uvres in doing business from the day he scared his 7 twenty Cleveland competitors until they sold to him at half price. You can also sell high, if you have a reputation of a great financier, and control of money and banks. Amalgamated Copper is an excellent example. The narjies of certain Standard Oil officials would float the most worthless property ---~on earth a few years ago. It might be a little difficult for to do so to-day with Amalgamated so fresh in mind. Indeed, Amalgamated seems to-day to be the worst "break," it certainly was one of the most outrageous performances the Standard Oil crowd. But that will soon be forgotten! The result is that the Standard Oil Company is probably~~ in the strongest financial position of any aggregation in the ~rld. And every year its position grows stronger, for every there is pouring in another $45,000,000 to be used in wiping up the property most essential to preserving and its power. And now what does the law of New Jersey require the concern which it has chartered, and which is so rapidly adding to control of oil the control of iron, steel, copper, banks, and railroads, to make known of itself? It must each year report its iame, the location of its registration office, with name of agent, character of its business, the amount of capital stock issued, Lfld ihe names and addresses of its officers and directors! So much for ~resent organisation, and now as to how far this organisation the Standard Oil Company is able realise the purpose for which it was organised-the control of the output, and, through that, the price, of refined oil. That is, what per cent. of the whole oil business does Mr. Rockefeller's concern control. First as to oil production. In 1898 the Standard Oil Company reported to the Industrial Commission that it produced 35.58 per cent. of Eastern cr -the production that year was about 52,000,000 barrels.e (It should be remembered that it is always to the Eastern oil fields-Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, West Virginia-that this narrative refers. Texas, -Kansas, Colorado and California are newer developments. These fields have not as yet been determining factors in the business, though Texas particularly has been a distributing factor.) But while Mr. Rockefeller produces only about a third of the entire production, he controls all but about ten per cent. of it; that is, all but about ten per cent. goes immediately into his custody on coming from the wells. It passes entirely out of the hands of the producers when the Standard pipe-line takes it. The oil is in Mr. Rockefeller's hands, and he, not the producer, can decide who is to have it. The greater portion of it he takes himself, of course, for he is the chief refiner of the country. In 1898 the~re were about~ twenty-four million barrels of petroleum products made in this country.t Of this amount about twenty million were made by the Standard Oil Company; fully a third of the balance was produced by the Tidewater Company, of which the Standard holds a large minority stock, and which for twenty years has had a running arrangement with the Standard. Reckoning out the Tidewater's probable output, and we have an independent output of about 2,500,000 in twenty-four million. It is obvious that this great percentage of the business gives the - -Standard the control of prices. This control can be kept in the domestic markets so long as the Standard can keep under competition as successfully as it has in the past. It can be kept in the foreign market as long as American oils can be made and sold in quantity cheaper than foreign oils. Until a decade Ago the foreign market of American oils was not seriously ned. Since 1895, however, Russia, whose annual out?ut of petroleum had been for a number of years about equal in volume to the American output, learned to make a fairly decent product; more dangerous, she had learned to market. She first appeared in Europe in i885. It took ten years to make her a formidable rival, but she is so to-day, and, in spite of temporary alliances and combinations, it is very doubtful whether the Standard will ever permanently control Russian oil. In 1899 Mr. Archbold presented to the Industrial Commission a most interesting list of foreign corporations and individuals doing an oil business in various countries. According to this there were more than a score of large concerns in Russia, and many small ones. The aggregate capitalisation by Mr. Archbold's list was over forty-six and a half Lons, and the capitalisation of a number of the concerns was not given. In Galicia, four companies, with an aggregate capital of $3,775,100, and in Roumania six large companies, with an aggregate capital of $12,500,000, were reported. Borneo was shown to have nearly three millions in-vested in the oil fields; Sumatra and Java each over twelve millions. Since this report was made these companies have grown, particularly in marketing ability. In the East the oil market belonged practically to the Standard Oil Company until recently. Last year (1903), however, Sumatra imported inore oil into China than America, and Russia imported nearly as much.into Calcutta last year, and of this only about six million gallons came from America. In Singapore representatives of Sumatra oil claim that they have two-thirds of the trade. Combinations for offensive and defensive trade campaigns have also gone on energetically among these various companies in the last few years. One of the largest and most powerf~ of these aggregations n6w at work is in connection with ati English shipping concern, the Shell Transport and Trading Company, the head of which is Sir Marcus Samuel, formerly Lord Mayor of London. This compan~y, which formerly traded -~almost entirely in Russian oil, undertook a few years ago to develop the oil fields in Borneo, and they built up a large Oriental trade. They soon came into hot competition with the Royal Dutch Company, handling Sumatra oil, and a war of prices ensued which lasted nearly two years. In 1903, how ever, the two competitors, in connection with four other strong Sumatra and European companies, drew up an agreemert -in regard to markets which has put an end to their war. The "Shell" people have not only these allies, but they -have a contract with the Guffey Petroleum Company, the largest Texas producing concern, to handle its output, and they have gone into a German oil company, the Petroleum Produktcn Aktien Gesellschaft. Having thus provided themselves with a supply they have begun developing a European trade on -~ the same lines as their Oriental trade, and they are making - Serious inroads on the Standard's market. The naphthas made from the Borneo oil have-largely taken the place of American naphtha in many parts of Europe. OIiL load of Borneo benzine even made its appearance in thL American market in 1904. It is a sign of what well miv happen in the future with an intelligent development --'.-f these Russian and Oriental oils-the Standard's domestic market invaded. It will be interesting to see to what further extent the American government will protect the Standard Oil Cpmpany by tariff on foreign oils if such a time does come. It has done very well already. The aggressive marketing of the "Shell" and its allies in Europe has led to a recent Oil War of great magnitude. For several months in 1904 Amencan export oil was sold at a lower price in New York than the crude oil it takes to make it costs there. For instance, on August 13, 1904, the New York export price was 4.80 -~cents per gallon for Standard-white in bulk. Crude sold at the well for $i.5o a barrel of forty-two gallons, and i~ costs ~itty cents to get it to seaboard by pipe-line; that is, forty-two g~llons of crude oil costs $2.10, or five cents a gallon in New York-twenty points loss on a gallon of the raw material! But this low price for export affects the local market little or none. The tank-wagon price keeps up to ten and eleven cents in New York. Of course crude is depressed as much as possible to help carry this competition. For many months now there has been the abnormal situation of a declining crude price in face of declining stocks. The truth is the Standard Oil Company is trying to meet the competition of the low-grade Oriental and Russian oils with high-grade American oil-the crude being kept as low as possible, and the domestic market being made to pay for the foreign cutting. It seems a lack of foresight surprising in the Standard to have allowed itself to be found in such a dilemma. Certainly, for over two ycars the company has been making every effort to escape b~ getting hold of a supply of low-grade oil which would enable it to meet the competition of the foreigner. There have h~~eri more or less short-lived arrangements in Russia. An oil ti~rntory in Galicia was secured not long ago by them, and ~n t~~\-pert refiner with a full refining plant was sent over. Various h~ndrances have been met in the undertaking, and the works e not yet in operation. Two years ago the Standard attempted t~A~ get hold of the rich Burma oil fields. The press of India fought them out of the country, and their weapon was the